Poor People Lose
Gideon v. Wainwright is the wrong cure for the reality that the carceral system is designed to target poor people.
6 posts in ‘sixth amendment’
Gideon v. Wainwright is the wrong cure for the reality that the carceral system is designed to target poor people.
As public defenders, we are not “fighting the system”—we are the system. Because of this, we have power, and the numbers, to change it.
People assigned a public defender are the only ones deprived of the right to choose their lawyer. This often intersects disastrously with racial bias.
The Court’s decision must not preempt questions about the role public defenders can play in ending mass incarceration.
Misdemeanors are major sources of overcriminalization and punishment. Requiring jurors to screen them could shake up the system.
We can celebrate the ascent of Ketanji Brown Jackson, while acknowledging that indigent defense remains woefully inadequate in this time of crisis.